Another conspiracy theory: LGB to T

20 Jun, 2023 by Barry 7 Comments

The LGB to T theory is a subset of wider “gender ideology” or “gender critical” theories, and is a conspiracy theory claiming that transgender activists are trying to recruit or groom lesbian, gay and bisexual people into becoming transgender. This theory is based on the false assumption that transgender people are not really their affirmed gender, but rather confused or deluded homosexuals, lesbians or bisexuals who have been influenced by “transgender ideology” whatever that is supposed to mean.

There are many arguments against this theory, but here are some that I think are worth considering:

• The theory is homophobic and transphobic, as it denies the existence and validity of transgender people and their identities, and implies that homosexuality and bisexuality are inferior or undesirable orientations.
• The theory is unscientific, as it ignores the overwhelming evidence that gender identity is a complex and innate aspect of human development, and that transgender people benefit from affirming their gender identity through social, medical and/or legal means.
• The theory is illogical, as it contradicts itself by claiming that transgender people are both a threat to and a product of lesbian, gay and bisexual communities, and by ignoring the diversity and fluidity of sexual orientation and gender expression among all people.
• The theory is unfounded, as it relies on anecdotal and sensationalised stories of detransitioners or regretters, who are a very small minority of transgender people, and who often face external pressures or barriers to accessing appropriate care.
• The theory is harmful, as it fuels stigma, discrimination and violence against transgender people, especially transgender youth, who are already vulnerable to rejection, bullying and suicide.

In the last decade, since learning I’m autistic, I have come to realise my understanding of gender does not comfortably sit with what I will term the neurotypical binary gender stereotype. Like many autistics, I struggle to understand many social constructs, including that of gender.

In coming to terms with who I am, I have done a lot of reading about gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexuality and sexual expression. I am stating my position here because I see a rise in hatred and violence against the LGBTQIA+ community, especially the transgender community. It has to stop. To those who hold a contrary view to my position as outlined above, in all probability I have already read, carefully considered and dismissed the perspective you hold, so do not attempt to argue your case here. Any such comment will be deleted, and the offender will likely be banned from further comment.