Another Spectrum

Personal ramblings and rants of a somewhat twisted mind

No Thanks Google

5 Comments

A few minutes after one o’clock this morning, my Android phone woke me up by sounding an alarm. The screen flashed up a warning that we were about to experience a magnitude 6 earthquake centered about 230 Km (140 miles) southeast of us. What the heck? An earthquake that far away at only magnitude six is not worth being woken up for, especially if it doesn’t occur. A few seconds later, the house gave an almost imperceptible squeak but no shake at all. A real letdown!.

It turns out that Aotearoa New Zealand is one of two nations (the other being Greece) where Google has rolled out a nationwide earthquake detection service using the accelerometers built into most Android phones. It started here in April, and while it might have been mentioned in the accompanying notes of an Android update (who reads the full list of changes that accompanies an update anyway?), I certainly didn’t notice this “improvement”.

When a phone detects vibrations it sends an alert to Google’s servers, and based on the number of phones that call home, Google attempts to work out if it caused by an earthquake, determines its location and magnitude, and then sends an alert to those in the affected area.

Supposedly the system will give those a little distance from the epicentre a few seconds notice ahead of the shock waves arriving, but the movement of the tectonic plates beneath this land is likely to fool a network of hundreds or thousands of motion sensitive phones. This was one such occasion.

The actual epicentre was hundreds of kilometres northwest of us and was caused by the subduction of the Pacific plate beneath the Australian plate. It was at a depth of 160Km (100 miles) and a magnitude of 5.1. In this type of quake, the energy waves travel along the plate and are felt where the plate reaches the surface – the east coast of the North Island and can be felt over a wide area. Those near the quake centre are unlikely to feel it at all.

My phone is configured to receive National Emergency Management Agency messages, which sends emergency messages regarding not only earthquakes, but many others, including covid-19 notices. I really don’t need another, especially one that’s as wildly inaccurate as Google’s.

Having discovered this new but unwanted “feature”, I decided to switch if off. I knew it had to be in the phone settings somewhere, but exactly where was not revealed after a careful search. The obvious solution was to Google. As I suspected, the instructions were easy to locate. Eight out of the first ten search results gave precise instructions on activating/deactivating earthquake notifications. None applied to my Huawei phone. In all eight case, the first step was to open “Settings” but from there on every step was different, and none were available on my phone. Back to the drawing board.

It took me almost an hour of drilling down through almost every Setting option before I eventually found it hidden in Settings > Security & privacy >Location Access > Advanced settings > Location services > Earthquake alerts. So obvious!

I appreciate that in some parts of the world, earthquakes are rare and dwellings are not designed with them in mind, so Google’s alert for earthquakes of 4.5 and higher might be appropriate. But in this country where earthquakes of that magnitude or greater occur several times a month, there’s only one way to describe the service: Bloody annoying!

Author: Barry

A post war baby boomer from Aotearoa New Zealand who has lived with migraines for as long as I can remember and was diagnosed as being autistic aged sixty. I blog because in real life I'm somewhat backwards about coming forward with my opinions.

5 thoughts on “No Thanks Google

  1. I installed the SoCal earthquake alert app but it must be left running at all times and I don’t let my apps do that, so it was useless and I uninstalled it.

    What is a noteworthy quake in your area? Here, most 6.0 within a hundred miles (160k) would be worth an alert, though damage would most likely occur only within 30m (48k).

    • Personally, I wouldn’t want to be notified unless there was a probability of injury. NZ buildings are designed to withstand severe quakes without collapsing. They may not be habitable afterwards. For example entire suburbs were demolished after the Christchurch earthquake although no loss of life occurred there. The deaths in Christchurch were primarily from the collapse of two commercial buildings that had been weakened by a severe earthquake several months earlier. They were permitted to be occupied before repairs had been completed.

      There have been several earthquakes since that have been stronger, and one in Wellington a few years ago has resulted in many significant buildings no longer able to be occupied and they are being demolished, but no lives were lost in the earthquake.

      I guess I would not want to receive notification unless an earthquake exceeded magnitude 7. Others might prefer something lower, but I doubt anyone would want notifications below 6. Google’s 4.5 threshold is ridiculously low.

      • 4.5?!?!?!?!? That’s programmed by someone who’s not used to quakes!!

        I would want to be able to spec min size by area… notify me of a 6 within 3 miles, but much higher beyond that range! And after a lifetime of not knowing how big a quake will get, warnings might be worse than better!

        • Magnitude 4.5 might be appropriate in places where earthquakes are rare – Australia and the UK for example.

          Wikipedia lists every UK earthquake from magnitude 1.5 upwards and lists only 3 being stronger than 4.5 since the start of this century, whereas for NZ it doesn’t list any below 5.7

          NZ is divided into 10 earthquake regions, and centered in just the region where I live, over the same period, there have been 98,936 earthquakes with a magnitude greater than 1.5, 297 greater than magnitude 4.5, and 31 greater than magnitude 6.0.

          In the last year alone, over the entire country, there has been 597,014 earthquakes stronger than magnitude 1.5, 9,227 stronger than magnitude 4.5, and 229 stronger than 6.0. Given that most significant earthquakes are felt over multiple regions, I certainly wouldn’t want to be notified of any below magnitude 6.0

          • I’m in SoCal… have experienced many 6.0+ quakes in my life. I say “4.0 or it doesn’t count!” Quite literally, trucks hitting the ditches in front of my house feel like 4.0!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s